Rows of young green seedlings growing in dark soil in a greenhouse

ETFs

How index ETFs work: tracking, costs and risks

How an index ETF copies a market index, why its price stays close to its holdings, what the expense ratio is, and the risks that remain.

Typical costFree
Time10 minute read
DifficultyEasy

Key takeaways

  • An index ETF aims to hold the same securities as an index, in about the same proportions.
  • You pay an annual expense ratio plus any trading costs, so compare both before buying.
  • A broad index ETF spreads company risk but can still lose money when the whole market falls.
  • This is general education, not advice; all investing involves risk of loss.

An index ETF is an exchange-traded fund that aims to hold the same securities as a market index, in about the same proportions, and that trades on an exchange throughout the day like a single stock. The SEC’s investor education materials describe this type of fund as one that seeks to track an index rather than relying on a manager to pick winners. Owning one share means owning a small slice of a pool of many investments. It does not mean owning a guaranteed result, and the value can fall as well as rise.

This guide covers what an index is, how a fund copies it, what keeps the share price close to the value of the holdings, what you pay, and where the structure can disappoint. It is general education, not investment advice.

What an index is

An index is a published list of securities with rules for who gets in and how much each one counts. You cannot buy an index directly. A fund company builds a fund that follows the list.

Many broad stock indexes weight each company by its total market value, which is called market-cap weighting. As a simple hypothetical, imagine a tiny market of 100 units of total value in which one company is worth 5 units. That company would be about 5% of the index, and a 10% move in its price would move the index by roughly half a percent, all else equal. Large companies therefore move a market-cap-weighted index more than small ones.

Indexes exist for many parts of the market, for example large companies, the broader stock market, companies outside the United States, or bonds. The name of the fund usually tells you which index it follows, and the fund’s own documents say so in detail. Read those before you buy.

How the fund copies the index

The SEC describes an index ETF as aiming to hold the securities in the index in the same proportions as the index. When the index changes its list, the fund adjusts its holdings to match. You do not make those trades yourself.

Some index funds hold every security in the index. Others hold a representative sample, which can make sense when an index has a very large number of securities that are hard to trade. Either way, the fund will not match the index exactly. The gap between the fund’s result and the index’s result is called tracking error or tracking difference, and it comes from fees, trading costs and the way the fund is built.

Because a passive fund only trades when its index changes, it generally trades less than a fund whose manager makes active decisions. Less trading can mean lower costs, but the fund’s documents are where you confirm how it actually behaves.

Why the price stays close to the holdings

An ETF has two numbers. The market price is what buyers and sellers agree on during the day. The net asset value, or NAV, is the per-share value of what the fund holds. The two can differ, so an ETF can trade at a small premium or discount to its NAV.

The SEC explains that large financial firms called authorized participants can create new ETF shares by delivering a basket of the underlying securities, or redeem shares by exchanging them for the underlying securities. That process is meant to keep the market price aligned with the value of the holdings. It does not guarantee they match at every moment, and the gap can widen when the underlying securities are hard to trade or markets are volatile.

Buying: orders and spreads

You buy an ETF through a brokerage account, the same way you buy a stock. Two details matter for beginners:

  • Bid-ask spread. The spread is the difference between the highest price a buyer is offering and the lowest price a seller is asking. It is a real cost each time you trade, and it tends to be wider for thinly traded ETFs.
  • Limit orders. The SEC points out that a limit order lets you set the price you are willing to pay or accept, which can be useful when prices are moving quickly. A market order fills at whatever the current price is.

Whether your brokerage charges commissions, and whether it offers fractional shares, depends on the provider. Check the fee schedule of the account you use.

What it costs: the expense ratio

Every fund charges an annual expense ratio, expressed as a percentage of the assets you hold in it. It is taken from the fund’s assets, so you do not receive a bill, and it reduces your result quietly. FINRA’s investor education also stresses that small fee differences add up over time, so it is worth comparing.

A hypothetical comparison of one year only: on $10,000, a fund charging 0.10% costs $10, while a fund charging 1.00% costs $100. Both figures are made up to show the arithmetic, not real funds. Over many years, the lower-cost fund keeps more of whatever the investments earn, but no one can say what that will be. The fund’s fact sheet and prospectus list its actual expense ratio, and these documents change, so read the current ones.

Trading costs are separate. They include the spread and any commission, so a cheap fund that you trade frequently can still be expensive to use.

What you own and what risk remains

A broad index ETF holds many securities, so the failure of one company has a limited effect on the fund. That is diversification, which FINRA describes as reducing the risk of major losses from over-emphasizing a single security or asset class.

Diversification does not remove market risk. If the whole market that the index covers falls, the fund is expected to fall with it, and there is no floor under its price. The SEC lists several risks of ETFs, including:

  • Market risk. The value of the underlying securities can drop.
  • Tracking error. The fund may not follow the index exactly.
  • Liquidity risk. Thinly traded ETFs can have wider spreads.
  • Concentration risk. Sector or theme ETFs focus on one narrow area and can be much riskier than a broad fund.

Market-cap weighting adds one more point: a few very large companies can make up a large share of a fund. The fund’s top holdings are listed on its fact sheet, so check them to see what you actually own. If you hold several funds, check whether they overlap, because five funds that hold mostly the same companies are less diversified than they look.

“ETF” describes how a fund trades, not how safe it is. Leveraged and inverse ETFs, which the SEC has issued separate investor bulletins about, carry very different risks from a plain broad index fund. Read the fund’s documents before buying one.

Taxes in plain terms

The SEC notes that the creation and redemption process lets many ETFs transfer securities in kind, which can reduce the taxable capital gains the fund distributes compared with some mutual funds. That is a tendency, not a promise. In a taxable account, dividends and gains can still create a tax bill, and tax rules differ by situation and change over time. The IRS publishes guidance on investment income, and a tax professional can answer questions about your own case.

Funds held inside a workplace plan or an individual retirement account follow that account’s rules instead. Roth vs traditional 401(k) for younger workers explains how the two common workplace account types differ.

Index ETF or index mutual fund

An index mutual fund follows the same kind of index but is priced once per day and bought or sold through the fund company or a broker. ETFs trade on exchanges throughout the day, while mutual funds are generally bought and redeemed at one end-of-day price. Many workplace plans offer only mutual funds. The idea behind them is the same, so the points above about indexes, costs and diversification apply to both.

If you are comparing a fund with a single company’s shares, what is the difference between stocks and ETFs lays out the trade-offs side by side.

Limits of an index ETF

  • You get the index’s result, less costs. You will not beat the index, and in a falling market you share the decline.
  • An ETF is a tool, not a plan. You still decide how much to hold in stocks versus bonds and when you will need the money. How to build a simple beginner portfolio walks through that sequence.
  • Easy trading can encourage bad habits. Because shares trade all day, it is tempting to react to headlines, which tends to add cost.
  • Past performance does not guarantee future results. Any chart of a fund’s history describes the past only.

Investing involves risk, including the loss of money you put in. If your situation is complicated, a licensed professional can look at your whole picture.

Where this comes from

This article is based on the SEC’s investor education bulletin on exchange-traded funds, and FINRA’s investor education pages on diversification and asset allocation. Fees, tax rules and fund details change, so check the current figures in the fund’s own documents and at the source before acting.